The two spouses left behind after a cheating scandal rocked “Good Morning America” are now engaged to each other, closing the book on one of network news’s messiest love triangles.
Quick Take
- Andrew Shue, 59, and immigration attorney Marilee Fiebig, 49, confirmed their engagement to People on October 21, 2026, after dating more than three years.
- Shue was married to Amy Robach and Fiebig to T.J. Holmes before the two “GMA3” anchors were caught in an affair and left ABC.
- Shue proposed to Fiebig this past spring, about a month after Robach and Holmes married privately.
- Both new couples came together only after their original marriages ended, according to published timelines.
A Scandal That Shook Morning Television
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes made headlines in late 2022 when photos surfaced showing the married “GMA3” co-anchors in a romantic relationship. Both were still legally married at the time to Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig. The fallout was swift. ABC pulled Robach and Holmes off the air, and both eventually left the network entirely, ending their on-screen partnership for good.
Robach and Holmes divorced their respective spouses in the aftermath. The scandal became a national tabloid story, with cable news and gossip outlets tracking every twist. Few expected the fallout to produce a second, quieter love story between the two people who were left behind by the affair.
From Heartbreak to New Beginnings
Shue and Fiebig began dating in 2023, not long after their divorces from Robach and Holmes were finalized, according to People’s relationship timeline. The two bonded over shared circumstances rather than any connection to the original scandal itself. Their relationship stayed mostly out of the spotlight for years, a contrast to the constant media coverage surrounding their former spouses.
Shue, known for his role on “Melrose Place” and his later work as a youth sports advocate, told People the relationship simply grew over time. “I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending,” Shue said, describing their path from shared heartbreak to a stable, long-term partnership. Fiebig, an immigration attorney, added that the couple feels “very grateful and hopeful” about their future together.
Two Couples, Two Weddings
Robach and Holmes married in a private ceremony last month, roughly three years after their relationship first became public. Their wedding appears to have prompted Shue and Fiebig to go public with their own engagement news, which they had kept quiet since the spring proposal. Both couples, in the end, chose marriage rather than staying in limbo after the original scandal upended four lives.
The timing has not gone unnoticed by entertainment outlets, which have framed the story as a rare case where every party involved eventually found a lasting relationship. Shue and Fiebig are both parents from their prior marriages, and reports note the couple’s engagement came together quietly before the public announcement this week.
What Comes Next
No wedding date has been announced for Shue and Fiebig. Both couples appear to be moving forward on their own timelines, with Robach and Holmes already married and Shue and Fiebig now planning their own ceremony. For a story that began with a very public betrayal, the ending reported so far involves two separate marriages rather than lingering bitterness.
Whatever one thinks of how the original relationship played out at ABC, the outcome reported by multiple outlets reflects something conservatives have long valued: people choosing commitment and marriage over staying unattached after painful breakups. Both sets of exes moved on, married, and built new families rather than treating divorce as a permanent dead end.
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' exes are now engaged — to each other.
Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, who were both left behind when the former ABC News anchors' extramarital affair blew up in 2022, quietly bonded as the scandal played out in public. On Wednesday, they confirmed… pic.twitter.com/FqAkArP3QG
— Fox News Flash (@FoxNews_Flash) October 22, 2026
The engagement caps a saga that captivated audiences for three years, from the initial scandal to two separate weddings. Shue and Fiebig’s path from shared heartbreak to their own engagement shows that even messy, headline-grabbing breakups can still end in lasting commitment for everyone involved.
Sources:
foxnews.com, people.com, latimes.com, pagesix.com, yahoo.com
